
Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26 this year, and you don’t have to spend it stuck in the kitchen. Plenty of Long Beach Island restaurants serve a full turkey dinner, and local caterers and markets will cook the whole feast for you to pick up. Then you can take a walk on the beach while someone else does the dishes.
We’ve grouped this guide into restaurants serving Thanksgiving dinner, takeout and catering, and what’s happening on LBI over the holiday weekend. Most places fill up fast, so book early.
Where to Eat Thanksgiving Dinner on LBI
Salt Kitchen & Bar at Hotel LBI (Ship Bottom)
Date: Thursday, November 26, 2026 Time: 1:00 – 5:00 PM Price: $72 pp Reservations: 609-467-8000 or hotellbi.com Address: 350 West 8th Street, Ship Bottom. Learn More.
Salt is serving a traditional Thanksgiving dinner in the hotel’s restaurant, right at the foot of the causeway. Last year it was a prix fixe menu, so expect the classics done in an upscale way. It’s an easy pick if you’re coming onto the island for the day.
The Gables (Beach Haven)
Date: Thursday, November 26, 2026 Time: 1:00 – 7:30 Price: $148 pp Reservations: 609-492-3553 or OpenTable Address: 212 Centre Street, Beach Haven. Make a Reservation.
The Gables is the island’s go-to for a special occasion, set in a Victorian inn from 1892 with candlelit dining rooms. They serve a three-course prix fixe Thanksgiving dinner through the afternoon and evening, plus a takeout option for anyone who’d rather eat at home.
Engleside Inn (Beach Haven)
Date: Thursday, November 26, 2026 Time: 2:00 – 7:00 Price: $37.95 adults and $18.95 children Reservations: 609-492-1251 or OpenTable Address: 30 Engleside Avenue, Beach Haven. Make a Reservation.
The oceanfront Engleside usually serves a traditional Thanksgiving dinner alongside its regular menu. That makes it a good choice for groups where not everyone wants turkey, since the prime rib and sushi bar are local favorites.
Buckalew’s Restaurant & Tavern (Beach Haven)
Date: Thursday, November 26, 2026 Time: All Day Price: Typically around $30 pp Reservations: 609-492-1065 Address: 101 North Bay Avenue, Beach Haven. Call for Reservation.
Buckalew’s is in a historic 1874 hotel and has traditionally stayed open on Thanksgiving with a turkey dinner and its full regular menu. It’s a more casual, tavern-style option, and it’s a short walk to the beach for an after-dinner stroll.
Just Over the Causeway: LBI National Golf & Resort
Date: Thursday, November 26, 2026 Time: 2:00 – 7:00 PM Price: Starting at $31.53 Reservations: 609-857-5656 or book online at lbinational.com Address: 99 Golf View Drive, Little Egg Harbor. Make a Reservation.
For a big family buffet, LBI National’s annual Thanksgiving spread is hard to beat. The menu includes antipasti and a fall salad, carved turkey with sausage and sage stuffing, candied yams, mashed potatoes, maple cranberry Brussels sprouts, and carving stations with prime rib and cider-brined turkey. Pumpkin pie, pecan pie and mini pastries finish it off.
Thanksgiving Takeout & Catering
Want the home-cooked feel without the cooking? These local spots have offered pre-ordered Thanksgiving meals in past years. Order deadlines are usually about a week before the holiday, and spots are limited, so call soon.
Black-Eyed Susans (Harvey Cedars)
Order by: November 20, 2026 Pickup: November 25, 2026 at 1:00 – 5:00 Phone: 609-494-4990 Address: 7908 Long Beach Boulevard, Harvey Cedars. Place Your Order.
This north-end favorite offers full Thanksgiving dinners by pre-order. Last year, pickup was the afternoon of Thanksgiving Eve.
The Local Market & Kitchen LBI (Ship Bottom)
Order by: November 21, 2026. Phone: 609-342-0061 Email: info@localmarketlbi.com Address: 604 Central Ave, Ship Bottom, NJ 08008. View Menu.
They have the entire meal covered from starters to entrees, sides, dessert and specialty breads.
Lighthouse Deli (Surf City)
Order by: November 20, 2026 Pickup: November 25, 2026. Phone: (609) 207-6167 Address: 1718 Long Beach Blvd, Surf City, NJ 08008 Place Your Order.
A great option for parties of all sizes. This favorite deli is offering meals for groups of two up to eight.
More Catering & Thanksgiving Options
Spice It Up Bay Village, 830 North Bay Avenue, Beach Haven: 609-492-1240. Learn More.
Grab a gobbler or join their 3rd annual Sip, Savor, Shop event Thanksgiving weekend. Nov 27th & 28th. They offer complimentary homemade banana crumb cake, Bloody Mary’s, and Hot Cocoa while you shop Small!
Make a Weekend of It: Thanksgiving Weekend on LBI
The holiday weekend is when LBI starts celebrating Christmas, so stick around after the leftovers:
- Friday, Nov 27 & 28th: Spice it Up’s 3rd annual Sip, Savor, Shop event. Complimentary homemade banana crumb cake, Bloody Mary’s, and Hot Cocoa while you shop Small!
- Friday, Nov 27, 6:00 PM: Santa’s Arrival & Tree Lighting, Barnegat Light. Santa arrives at the 10th Street ramp, then rides a fire truck to the old Borough Hall for the tree lighting and carols.
- Saturday, Nov 28, 10:00 AM – 4:00 PM: Santa’s Viking Christmas Village, Barnegat Light. A free holiday craft show with 40+ artists, live music and Santa’s fire truck arrival at 1 PM.
- Saturday, Nov 28, 5:00 – 6:30 PM: Ship Bottom Christmas Tree Lighting at the municipal ramp on West 10th Street.
- Saturday, Nov 28: “Holiday Inn” opens at Surflight Theatre, Beach Haven, with matinee and evening shows running into December.
- Saturday, Nov 28 (TBA): Thanks 4 Giving 5K & 1 Mile Fun Run, Beach Haven. This race has run Thanksgiving Saturday morning in past years. Check for 2026 registration.
- Through Sunday, Nov 29: the Long Beach Island Surf Fishing Classic wraps up its 72nd year.
- Small Business Saturday: Shop local at the island’s year-round boutiques, galleries and markets.
Tips for Thanksgiving on LBI
- Book now. Island restaurants have limited off-season seating, and Thanksgiving reservations go quickly.
- Order takeout early. Most caterers cap orders and close them about a week out.
- Ask about the regular menu. Several spots serve their usual menu alongside the turkey dinner, which helps with picky eaters.
- Walk it off on the beach. A post-dinner stroll on a quiet November beach is an LBI Thanksgiving tradition all its own.
Know of a Thanksgiving dinner or special we missed? Let us know and we’ll add it to the list.

Leave a Reply